Homemade Greek Yogurt

So in an attempt to eat healthier, reduce waste (specifically plastic), and know what is in every thing I consume — whether it is something I eat or something I put on my face — I have been homemaking a lot more food I’d normally buy at the store. One example: greek yogurt.

We can go through two plastic containers a week of this stuff! We eat it for a snack, for breakfast, and in place of sour cream. It is truly a staple for us.

Last week, I looked up a few different recipes and played around. Here is what I found that worked!

Ingredients:

  • 4 C Milk (preferably whole)
  • 1/4 C Greek (or other) yogurt – choose your favorite because it will take on the flavor and texture

Note: Make sure you check to ensure “live cultures” are on the ingredient list for the yogurt you use

Tools:

  • Liquid measuring cup
  • Candy thermometer
  • Pot
  • Bowl
  • Cheese cloth or dish towel
  • Sieve

Directions:

  1. Turn your oven on to it’s lowest setting
  2. Warm milk in pot on the stove at medium heat stirring regularly
  3. When the candy thermometer reads 185-200 degrees Farenheight (if you swirl the milk around the temperature will likely fluctuate) place the pot in a ice water bath (filling up the sink with the pot in it and adding ice works the best)
  4. When the temperature reads 100-110 degrees Farenheight drain the water from the sink
  5. Put the greek yogurt in the bowl and add 1/4 C milk mixing until smooth
  6. Add another 1/4 C milk
  7. Return the greek yogurt and milk mixture to the pot and mix thoroughly
  8. Place the pot in the warmed oven and turn off the oven
  9. Let it sit for 4-8 hours (overnight works well)
    Note: you may want to occasionally turn the oven on to the lowest setting again to keep the yogurt a little warmer than room temperature
  10. Place the sieve on the bowl with the cheese cloth or dish towel over it
  11. Put the greek yogurt mixture into the sieve on top of the cheese cloth or dish cloth
  12. Set in the fridge for another 8 hours occasionally pouring the liquid out of the bowl (this can be used as a thickener for soups and the like)
  13. Bon Appétit! Your yogurt is now ready to eat. Store in an airtight container for up to a week

This makes a super creamy and flavorful greek yogurt. It is easy to add your sweetener or flavor of choice in a single serving or to the entire thing once made.

I hope you enjoy!

Leave a comment